Who Pays the Tax When You Send an Employee Abroad? Tax Equalization Explained
Send someone to Dubai and the host-country tax bill may be close to nothing. Send them to Berlin on the same package and the cost can climb by tens of thousands of dollars a year. Here's how tax equalization, hypothetical tax and shadow payroll decide it.
The question to settle before anyone books a flight
When you send an employee to work in another country, someone has to cover the gap between the tax they'd have paid at home and the tax they'll owe abroad. It can be the employee, the company, or a split agreed in advance. If nobody decides, the employee decides for you. They'll negotiate a higher salary, refuse the move, or come back angry after their first host-country tax return.
Most companies need a written assignee tax policy by the time two or three people are on cross-border assignments. That policy sets your cost model. Expat tax services for employees, whether from a Big Four firm, a mid-tier accountant or a specialist mobility provider, then put it into practice: they estimate the cost before the move, support payroll during it, and prepare returns afterward.
This piece covers the three common policy types, how hypothetical tax and shadow payroll work, and why one package can cost very different amounts depending on the destination. It also covers what to expect from a provider and when you need a licensed adviser. Everything here describes how these arrangements generally work. Tax rules change and depend on each person's facts, so confirm specific figures with qualified professionals in both countries.
Tax equalization, tax protection and laissez-faire compared
Almost every assignment policy is built on one of three approaches. The differences matter more than the names suggest.
| Policy | What the employee pays | Who keeps the upside | Who carries the risk | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tax equalization | The same as if they'd stayed home, deducted as hypothetical tax | The company, when host tax is lower | The company, when host tax is higher | Multi-country programs and rotating assignees |
| Tax protection | Whichever is lower: home tax or actual tax | The employee | The company, when host tax is higher | Moves to low-tax locations where you want the move to feel like a reward |
| Laissez-faire | Whatever the host and home countries actually charge | The employee | The employee | Permanent transfers, local-plus hires and self-requested moves |
A tax equalization policy is the default for companies with more than a handful of assignees, and for good reason. The employee's take-home pay doesn't depend on the destination. People become more willing to go where the business needs them, and an assignee in Singapore and one in Frankfurt stay on the same footing. The cost is administrative: hypothetical tax calculations, annual reconciliations and an adviser who understands both tax systems.
Tax protection is easier to sell to employees but costs more over a full program. The company pays for every high-tax posting and gets nothing back from the low-tax ones. Laissez-faire is cheap to run but works badly for temporary moves you initiated. It makes sense when the employee asked to relocate permanently.
How hypothetical tax keeps the employee whole
Hypothetical tax is the mechanism that makes equalization work. The company estimates what the employee would have paid in home-country income tax and social contributions on home-equivalent pay, and deducts that amount from salary throughout the assignment. In return, the company pays the actual host-country taxes, plus any home-country tax still due.
Assignment allowances are usually left out of the hypothetical calculation. That includes housing, cost-of-living adjustments, school fees and home leave. The employee wouldn't have received them at home, so they shouldn't bear tax on them. This one design choice drives much of the company's cost, because host countries often tax those allowances as employment income.
Hypothetical example: say an employee earns $150,000 base pay at home and would normally pay about $35,000 in income tax and social contributions. During the assignment, the company deducts roughly $2,900 a month as hypothetical tax. After year-end, a provider prepares an equalization calculation. It replaces the estimate with the true home-equivalent figure, reflecting bonuses and family changes, and settles the difference in either direction. Personal income, such as rent from a home they let out or investment gains, normally stays the employee's responsibility. Your policy should say so explicitly.
Why you still need a shadow payroll
Many companies keep the assignee on the home payroll so pension, benefits and service history continue. That's sensible. But many host countries expect income tax to be withheld locally once the person works there, and sometimes social security too, even when no local entity pays them. A shadow payroll is a parallel payroll in the host country. It calculates and remits local withholding on the full package without paying any net salary, because the cash still comes from home.
Requirements vary widely. Germany and the UK, for example, can require withholding where a local host company bears the cost of the assignee, even if the formal employer is elsewhere. Singapore leans more on annual filing and employer reporting than on monthly withholding for most employees. The UAE has no personal income tax to withhold, though the home country may still require reporting. India, Australia and several Latin American countries have their own thresholds and registration rules.
Shadow payroll also needs inputs most payroll teams don't track well: benefits in kind, equity vesting, split-year residency and exchange rates. If you have no host entity, an employer of record can sometimes act as the local employer. That changes who the legal employer is, which affects your equalization policy and benefits continuity.
Same package, three destinations: UAE, Singapore and Germany
Take one package and send it to three cities. Hypothetical, simplified example: $150,000 base salary, a $50,000 housing allowance and $20,000 in other allowances, for $220,000 a year. The employee is on tax equalization with hypothetical tax of about $35,000. They're single, with no other income, and stay two years. The figures below are rough orders of magnitude showing how costs behave. They aren't tax calculations.
| Destination | Host income tax (rough) | Main cost drivers | Net cost to the company vs. hypothetical tax |
|---|---|---|---|
| UAE (Dubai) | None on employment income | Whether the employee stays tax-resident at home (some countries tax citizens wherever they live); corporate tax and permanent-establishment exposure for the company | Often negative: the company keeps most of the hypothetical tax if no home tax is due |
| Singapore | Moderate; progressive resident rates with a top rate in the low-to-mid 20s percent | How employer-provided housing is taxed; non-resident treatment in a short first year; generally no mandatory social contributions for foreigners | Roughly neutral, within a range of a few thousand dollars either way |
| Germany | High; top rates above 40% plus a solidarity surcharge in some cases | Taxable allowances; social security unless a certificate of coverage applies; gross-up on company-paid tax | Often tens of thousands of dollars a year once grossed up |
Germany is expensive because of the gross-up. When the company pays the employee's tax, that payment is itself taxable income. At a marginal rate around 40-45%, covering $1 of extra tax can cost the company roughly $1.70-$1.80. A $50,000 gap between actual and hypothetical tax can therefore turn into something near $90,000. Add social security where no EU A1 form or bilateral certificate of coverage applies, and the total grows further.
The UAE has its own trap. Companies assume zero tax means zero work. But if the employee stays resident at home, because of family ties, days spent there or a citizenship-based system, home-country tax can return. If the assignee signs contracts locally, the company can also create a taxable presence in the UAE.
What competent expat tax services for employees should handle
A good provider runs the whole cycle, not just the returns. When you compare expat tax services for employees, check for these:
- Pre-assignment cost projection: a multi-year estimate covering gross-up, social security and both countries. Insist on it before the offer goes out, not after.
- Tax briefings: separate sessions with the assignee at departure and arrival, covering residency, filing deadlines and what counts as personal income.
- Hypothetical tax calculation and annual equalization settlement, with written workings the employee can follow.
- Shadow payroll setup and monthly inputs, or coordination with your payroll or EOR vendor.
- Assignee tax compliance: home and host returns, departure and arrival filings, and claims for treaty relief and foreign tax credits.
- Social security certificates (A1 forms or certificates of coverage) and tracking of their expiry dates.
- Day-count and business-traveler tracking to catch residency and permanent-establishment risk.
- Equity compensation sourcing across countries for shares that vest during or after the move.
Typical 2026 market ranges, which vary by firm, country and contract: roughly $1,500-$5,000 per assignee per country for annual returns, $1,000-$3,000 for an equalization calculation, and $1,000-$3,000 for a cost projection. Shadow payroll often runs about $50-$200 per employee per month, sometimes with a setup fee. Big Four firms tend to price at or above the top of these ranges. Mid-tier firms and specialist mobility providers are often cheaper for programs under 20 people. Confirm quotes in writing.
Red flags: no in-country partner in the destination, cost projections without a gross-up, equalization settlements delivered long after year-end, and no clear owner for the shadow payroll.
When to bring in a licensed adviser and how to pick a policy
A provider runs the process. Some decisions need a licensed tax adviser, or an employment lawyer, who answers for the advice. Bring one in before the move when:
- The employee is a citizen of a country that taxes by citizenship, or might keep tax residency at home.
- The assignment involves equity, carried interest or deferred compensation.
- The employee will negotiate contracts or sign deals in the host country, which creates permanent-establishment risk.
- No social security agreement exists between the two countries.
- The move is open-ended, or might become permanent partway through.
The rule of thumb: for temporary assignments you initiate, expected to last up to about five years, use tax equalization. Use tax protection only if most of your moves go to low-tax locations and you want that to feel like a benefit. Use laissez-faire for permanent transfers and moves the employee asked for. Then, before your next offer letter, ask your provider for a two-year cost projection that includes gross-up. Expect the Germany-type number to change some plans.
Quick answers
Does the company get to keep the hypothetical tax if the employee moves somewhere with no income tax?
Under a standard tax equalization policy, yes. The employee's net pay stays what it would have been at home, and the hypothetical tax deducted helps fund program costs elsewhere. Some companies share part of the saving to encourage low-tax postings, but that's a policy choice, not a requirement. Tell employees before they leave so it doesn't surprise them.
Do we need a shadow payroll if the employee is only abroad for a few months?
Often, yes, though it depends on the country. Some countries require withholding from the first day of work. Others exempt short stays under a tax treaty, provided the employee stays under a day threshold (commonly 183 days) and no local entity bears the cost. Get a written answer from a host-country adviser before the assignment starts.
Can an employer of record handle tax equalization for our assignees?
An employer of record (EOR) can usually run local payroll and withholding, which covers part of the shadow payroll work. Most don't calculate hypothetical tax, settle equalization or prepare home-country returns. Using an EOR also changes who the legal employer is, so check how that affects your policy, pension continuity and any social security certificates.
Written by the Expat Team Group editorial team. Prices, features and rules change often - confirm details with the vendor or a licensed professional before you decide.